November 20, 2026

Tyra Ali of Markel Tax discusses how to prepare for upcoming changes to CIS Compliance

0
Markel-Tax-_0000_Tyra-Ali

HMRC activity in the construction industry has been ramping up over the last few years but this year’s measures see a wave of new regulations and legislation coming in thick and fast.  Latest data shows construction output has risen this year which signals the need for firms to carry out more detailed compliance checks and ensure tighter due diligence to meet their employment status and CIS obligations as the industry responds to changing market conditions.

Several updates affecting the Construction Industry were introduced this year and one thing is certain; compliance can no longer be treated as a passive administrative function operating in the background, it’s now a key part of managing commercial risk. Just one mistake could immediately impact and change the course of a business overnight:

NIL returns

The CIS scheme re-introduced the requirement for contractors to submit NIL returns, meaning even if no payments have been made within the relevant period a return must be sent to HMRC (or notification must be sent to HMRC well in advance).  This underpins HMRC commitment to compliance of CIS, and if NIL returns are not submitted this will constitute a compliance failure and will trigger the penalties regime.

Construction Fraud liability

The “knew or should have known” test was introduced in April this year and is aimed at tackling supply chain fraud and will allow HMRC to cancel gross payment status to recover lost tax and impose penalties on businesses that knew or should have known payments were linked to fraud. The principal stems from the Kittel case relating to VAT and has now been extended to CIS to further strengthen HMRC’s powers.

Going forward HMRC does not need to show a business was actively involved in or benefited from fraud or wrongdoing. Instead it will be enough to show that the only reasonable explanation of a transaction was that it was connected to fraud and that a reasonable person in the taxpayer’s position would have recognised and investigated a potential risk.

The test sits somewhere between having actual knowledge and simple negligence and catches situations where warning signs were present but deliberately ignored.  In practice, this means contractors may be treated as having “known” about fraud where they failed to act on clear red flags such as unusually low pricing, failure to verify CIS status, inconsistent subcontractor behaviour or subcontractors disappearing after receiving gross payments.

Carrying out due diligence and keeping robust and well‑documented records will be essential to defending a “should have known” allegation and protecting gross payment status.

Joint and Several Liability

The new Umbrella legislation came into effect in April 2026 which has fundamentally shifted the risk across labour supply chains by introducing ‘joint and several’ liability for unpaid PAYE and NICs which means HMRC can recover the full liability from other parties higher up in the chain including agencies and, in some cases, end clients.

What is becoming clear is that main contractors can no longer assume compliance sits with the umbrella and understanding who is actually paying workers and how those arrangements operate in practice will be vital.

Perhaps more significantly, another key measure within the umbrella legislation is the introduction of “purported umbrella” arrangements. Effectively where an end-client business has reason to suppose that an individual is employed then this could bring the company engaging that individual into the definition of “purported umbrella”.  This means that where supply chains are not transparent and individuals are being provided on a self-employed basis HMRC may challenge those individuals should have been taxed as employees.  This would give rise to Tax and NI liabilities to the engager and any relevant party they contract to.

To safeguard your business against any of the new measures is simple – due diligence.  If businesses haven’t done so already, they should take the time to review they are meeting their CIS obligations and they understand their supply chain arrangements and the employment status of their workforce.

Gross Payment Status renewals are likely to receive closer attention making it important for businesses to ensure its meeting core CIS tests and demonstrate consistent compliance across the broader supply chain. Maintaining robust processes will be key to supporting successful renewals and avoiding disruption to businesses.

Contractors are encouraged to ensure their house is in order and may benefit from reviewing their internal processes, to ensure records and processes are up to date and they are maintaining clear documentation across their labour supply chains.

Leave a Reply