November 20, 2026

Councils failing on housing hold a quarter of England’s Green Belt, and 21 of them are now planning battlegrounds

a car is parked in front of a house

The councils furthest behind on housing delivery cover less than 12% of England’s land but hold more than a quarter of its Green Belt. In 21 of them, a failing delivery score, majority Green Belt and above-average house prices all apply at once.

The councils under most pressure from England’s new planning rules are also among those with the most Green Belt and the least affordable homes, according to Planning By Design’s analysis of three official datasets.

Last month, the national architectural design and town planning consultancy found that 93 of England’s 301 local planning authorities recorded a 2025 Housing Delivery Test result below 75%, and that more than half of them are in London and the South East.

Under Policy S5 of the new National Planning Policy Framework (NPPF), in force since 17 August, a result below 75% is treated as evidence of unmet housing need for certain development outside settlement boundaries. The same evidence is relevant to the unmet need test in the grey belt policy.

Planning By Design has now matched every council’s result against MHCLG’s Green Belt statistics and the ONS ratio of house prices to earnings. The analysis has been updated with MHCLG’s latest Green Belt figures, published on 22 October, and its findings are unchanged.

The Green Belt is where the shortfall sits

Of the 93 councils below 75%, 91 could be matched across all three datasets. Together they hold 418,440 hectares of Green Belt, 25.6% of England’s total, while covering 11.8% of its land.

Green Belt covers 27.1% of the land in those councils, compared with 12.5% across England as a whole. Fifty-seven of the 91 contain some Green Belt, and in 25 it covers at least half of the council’s land.

Aaron Basi, Chartered Town Planner and Head of Planning at Planning By Design, said:

“Green Belt and housing delivery are usually treated as two separate debates. This data shows they sit on top of each other. In these areas a failing delivery score now counts as evidence of unmet need, much of the land around existing towns is Green Belt, and homes are well beyond what local earnings can reach. That is where applications, refusals and appeals under the new framework are most likely to concentrate.”

The 21 battlegrounds

Planning By Design defines a Green Belt battleground as a council where three things apply at once: a Housing Delivery Test result below 75%, Green Belt covering at least half of its land, and a house price to earnings ratio above the England figure of 7.63.

Twenty-one councils meet all three tests. Together they hold 272,200 hectares of Green Belt, a sixth of England’s total. Over the three years to March 2025, they delivered 21,827 homes against a requirement of 48,065, a combined delivery rate of 45% and a shortfall of 26,238 homes.

Nine are in the East of England: Basildon, Castle Point, Dacorum, Epping Forest, Hertsmere, St Albans, Thurrock, Three Rivers and Welwyn Hatfield. Eight are in the South East: Elmbridge, Gravesham, Mole Valley, Sevenoaks, Spelthorne, Tandridge, Tonbridge and Malling, and Windsor and Maidenhead. Two are in London, Bromley and Havering, and two are in the West Midlands, Bromsgrove and Solihull.

Sevenoaks delivered 523 of the 2,130 homes required of it, a result of 25%. It has 34,390 hectares of Green Belt, the largest area of any council below 75%, covering 92.9% of the district, and the typical home costs 13.43 times typical local earnings.

Tandridge in Surrey has the highest Green Belt share of any council below 75%, at 93.9% of its land. Castle Point has the lowest delivery result of the 21, at 11%, while Elmbridge (15.74) and St Albans (15.01) have the least affordable homes.

Not only a southern story

All 21 battlegrounds are in the East of England, the South East, London and the West Midlands, but the overlap between failing delivery and Green Belt reaches further north.

Kirklees (65%) and Bradford (56%) hold the third and fourth largest areas of Green Belt among the councils below 75%, at 24,990 and 23,880 hectares, covering 61.2% and 65.2% of their land. Their house price to earnings ratios, 6.25 and 5.17, sit below the England figure, so neither meets the battleground definition. The pressure in West Yorkshire is failing delivery and extensive Green Belt, without the price pressure found around London.

Across England, the typical council below 75% has a house price to earnings ratio of 9.32, against 7.46 for councils that passed the test at 95% or above. Forty-three per cent of councils below 75% have a ratio of 10 or more, compared with 18% of those at 95% or above.

What it does not mean

Planning By Design is warning that the findings should not be read as a map of where the Green Belt will be built on.

A failing Housing Delivery Test result is not planning permission, and Green Belt designation is not an allocation for housing. Green Belt land remains subject to its own distinct policy framework, and the stronger general support for development elsewhere in the NPPF does not override it. Any proposal still has to meet every test that applies to its site, from design and highways to drainage, heritage, landscape and biodiversity.

Basi said:

“None of this means the Green Belt in these areas is about to be built on. What changes is how hard the arguments will be fought, and how much depends on getting the evidence right from the start. In a battleground authority, a weak application is likely to be refused and a weak refusal is likely to be tested at appeal.”

Planning By Design advises anyone with land, a live application or an appeal in a battleground council to make sure their case addresses the new framework from the outset.

The full analysis, including the table of all 21 battlegrounds, is available at https://planning-by-design.co.uk/green-belt-battlegrounds-new-planning-rules/