Nick Carter, Zaynub Akbar welcome Welsh Government decision to call in controversial data centre plans in Cardiff
After months of campaigning Plaid Cymru MSs in Caerdydd Ffynnon Taf hail major step forward for community
Plaid Cymru Members of the Senedd Nick Carter and Zaynub Akbar have welcomed the Welsh Government’s decision to call in the Cardiff Council controversial plans for a 7-storey data centre at Cardiff East Park and Ride, following months of opposition.
The decision means Cardiff Council will no longer determine the application. Instead, an independent planning inspector, PEDW, will examine the proposals before a final decision is made on whether the development goes ahead.
The two MSs, who represent Caerdydd Ffynnon Taf, have opposed the development since their election in May and have written to the Welsh Government on several occasions expressing concerns and requesting intervention.
- They highlighted significant changes to the proposed power plant, errors acknowledged by the developer’s own noise consultants and gaps in the environmental evidence.
- They also raised questions about the proposed power plant’s 49.9MW capacity. This fell just 0.1MW below the 50MW threshold at which any qualifying generating station falls within Wales’s significant infrastructure planning regime. They asked Ministers to consider whether the energy centre should be treated as a significant infrastructure project.
- The MSs also raised concerns about Cardiff Council’s overlapping roles as landowner, prospective landlord and planning authority, particularly given the developer’s assessment of increased flood depths on Council-owned land.
Nick Carter MS said:
“This is the right decision and a major step forward for everyone who has fought to protect this community. We asked the Welsh Government to step in because a development of this scale, with risks this serious, deserves the closest possible scrutiny. The more closely we’ve examined this application, the more troubling the questions have become.
“There are also serious questions about Cardiff Council’s role in this. The Council owns the land, stands to become the developer’s landlord, and was also responsible for deciding whether the development should go ahead. The developer is forecasting 125 operational jobs, compared with around 1,000 estimated for the business park scheme that already has planning permission on that site. Local people are being asked to shoulder the environmental risks without a convincing case that they will see the economic benefits.”
“We recognise that Wales needs strategic digital infrastructure and that well-planned developments can bring investment and skilled jobs. But those benefits must be real, with responsible energy and water use, and they must not come at the expense of people’s health or the environment.”
“This is the wrong development in the wrong place. We’ve made that case from the beginning, and we’ll continue making it until the final decision is taken.
We’re feeling more confident now that the decision now lies with an independent, experienced body”
Zaynub Akbar MS said:
“This is a victory for the people of Llanrumney, Pentwyn, Rumney and east Cardiff who refused to be ignored. They stood up for their communities and they’ve made their voices heard.”
“To everyone who wrote an objection, came to a meeting, read through the plans, spoke to their neighbours or helped someone else have their say: you have made a difference. We’ve stood alongside residents, challenging the developer, raising their concerns in the Senedd and pushing Welsh Ministers to step in. I’m delighted that they’ve listened.”
“But let’s be absolutely clear. The data centre has not been rejected. The call-in is an important step, not the final victory.”
“The profits of big tech must never come before the health and wellbeing of our communities. Residents deserve more than reassurances. They deserve clear answers, credible evidence and a planning decision that puts people first. We will keep standing with this community, making sure residents are heard and fighting for the right outcome.”